Not in the new shop yet

Delivered anywhere in the UK

Replacing an Old Shop Sign: Over the Top or Strip It?

If the old sign is flat, firmly fixed and unlit, a new sign tray or aluminium panel can often go straight over it, as long as the new sign is big enough to cover every edge and fixing hole. Strip it back if the old sign is loose, damaged, lit, bulky, or if the fascia behind it is rotten. Either way, check permission if the new sign is lit, bigger or on a listed building.

A printed sign tray starts at £150 and a flat aluminium sign at £25.50, inc VAT.

By the Liberty Signs team · Updated 22 Nov 2026 · 3 min read

Work it out with your own numbersPlanning Permission CheckerTry It

When Fitting Over the Top Works

Going over the top saves the cost and mess of removing the old sign, and it leaves no holes or marks on show. It works best when:

  • the old sign is flat, or close to it, such as an old panel or a painted board
  • it is firmly fixed, with no movement when you push it
  • it is unlit, or its lighting has already been safely disconnected
  • the new sign can be at least as big as the old one, so it covers every edge, mark and fixing hole

A sign tray suits this well, because its folded edges wrap around the outline and its fixing angles screw through to the fascia. A flat aluminium sign is a 3mm rigid panel that can also sit over a sound, flat surface.

When to Strip It Back

Take the old sign down first when:

  • it is loose, cracked or coming away, because a new sign is only as secure as what it is fixed to
  • the timber or render behind it is rotten or crumbling
  • it is illuminated: lit signs are wired to the mains, so a qualified electrician should disconnect and make the supply safe
  • it is a deep box or has individual letters that a new sign cannot sit flat over
  • you want a narrower or shorter sign, or a different shape, that would leave part of the old one showing

Expect what is underneath to need some work. Old fixings leave holes, and the fascia behind may be faded or damaged. If it is too far gone to paint, a flat aluminium sign cut to the full fascia size can act as a new face, with your sign tray or lettering on top.

What to Check Before You Order

  • Measure both: the fascia and the old sign, in millimetres, at more than one point. If the new sign goes over the old one, it needs to be at least the old sign's size. Our guide to measuring for a shop sign covers how.
  • What is on it: note lights, cameras, alarm boxes, cables and shutter boxes, with their positions.
  • What it is made of: if you can, find out what the old sign is and what sits behind it, such as timber, render or an old panel.
  • Photos: a straight-on photo of the whole shopfront and close-ups of both ends. Send them with your order and they help us check the proof.

Permission When You Change the Sign

A new sign needs the same permissions as any sign, even if it replaces one that has been up for years. You always need the building owner's permission, so if you rent, ask your landlord.

In England, under the Town and Country Planning (Control of Advertisements) (England) Regulations 2007, an unlit sign on your own business premises often has deemed consent if its letters are no more than 750mm high and its top is no higher than 4.6m or the bottom of the first-floor window, whichever is lower. If the new sign is lit, bigger or higher than the old one, or the building is listed or in a conservation area, check with your council before you order. If the old sign needed consent, do not assume that covers a new design. Our planning permission guide has the detail.

Choosing the New Sign, and Fitting It

For most replacements, one of our three sign trays is the natural choice:

Signs are supply only, and we can arrange fitting, including taking the old sign down. Send your photos and measurements on our quote page and we will price it for your site. Our guide to fixing a sign covers what is involved if you fit it yourself.

This guide is general information, not legal advice. Rules change and every site is different, so check with your council and your landlord before you order.

Sources: GOV.UK: Outdoor advertisements and signs, a guide for advertisers, legislation.gov.uk: The Town and Country Planning (Control of Advertisements) (England) Regulations 2007, Planning Portal: Advertisement consent

Common Questions

  • Often, yes, if the old sign is flat, firmly fixed and unlit, and the new one is big enough to cover every edge and fixing hole. If it is loose, lit or the fascia behind is rotten, take it down first.
  • A qualified electrician should disconnect the supply and make it safe before the sign comes down. We can arrange removal and fitting on a quote.
  • You need the building owner's permission. In England many unlit signs have deemed consent within limits, but a lit, bigger or higher sign, or a listed building, usually means checking with your council first.
  • If it goes over the old sign, at least the old sign's size, so nothing shows round the edges. Measure both in millimetres and send us photos if you are unsure.
  • ChloeChloeAndreaAndreaWilliamWilliamTalk to Our Team0161 399 0695Mon–Fri 8:00 to 16:30Visit SupportSend us a message or check an orderOr message us onWhatsApporEmail

Price Your New Sign

Enter the size of your fascia and see the price, or send us photos and we will price fitting too.